What is VAR (Vacuum Arc Remelting)?

Description

Vacuum arc remelting (VAR) is a secondary refining process that remelts steel under vacuum using an electric arc. It removes dissolved gases like hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen to produce extremely clean steel used in the highest-grade tool steels and aerospace alloys.

What is VAR (Vacuum Arc Remelting)?

Vacuum arc remelting (VAR) is a secondary steelmaking process where a consumable electrode is remelted under high vacuum using a direct-current electric arc. The vacuum environment removes dissolved gases — hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen — that would otherwise form inclusions or cause embrittlement. The result is steel of exceptional purity and uniformity.

Why It Matters for Scissors

Dissolved gases in steel create microscopic defects that compromise edge quality. Hydrogen causes hairline cracks (hydrogen embrittlement), oxygen forms hard oxide inclusions, and nitrogen can create brittle nitride phases in certain compositions. While standard scissor steels manage these issues through conventional degassing, VAR represents the ultimate solution for gas-related defects.

VAR-processed steels typically achieve total oxygen content below 10 ppm and hydrogen below 1 ppm — roughly half the levels achievable by ESR alone. For scissors operating at the extreme end of performance (ultra-hard steels at HRC 64+, or extremely thin convex edges), this additional cleanliness translates to fewer microscopic defects along the cutting edge.

The technology is most relevant to the premium end of the scissor market where cost is secondary to performance. A VAR-processed steel billet costs significantly more than a conventionally produced equivalent, but for manufacturers targeting the top 1% of the professional market, the quality improvement justifies the premium.

Technical Detail
The VAR process operates as follows: **Setup:** A consumable electrode (the primary steel product — often an ESR ingot for double-remelted grades) is suspended in a water-cooled copper crucible inside a sealed vacuum chamber. The chamber is evacuated to approximately 0.1-1.0 Pa (about 10⁻³ to 10⁻² torr). **Melting:** A direct-current arc is struck between the bottom of the electrode (cathode) and a starter pad in the crucible. The arc generates temperatures exceeding 5,000°C at the electrode tip, melting the steel. Droplets fall through the vacuum into a molten pool at the bottom of the crucible. **Degassing:** As steel droplets are exposed to the vacuum (extremely low partial pressure of gases), dissolved gases diffuse out: - **Hydrogen** is removed most efficiently — VAR reduces H content to below 1 ppm - **Oxygen** is partially removed through CO formation (C + O → CO gas, which is pumped away) - **Nitrogen** is reduced moderately, depending on the steel composition and alloy content **Solidification:** The molten pool solidifies directionally from bottom to top and from the water-cooled crucible walls inward. This controlled solidification reduces macro-segregation and produces a columnar grain structure that is subsequently refined during hot working. Key differences between VAR and ESR: | Parameter | VAR | ESR | |-----------|-----|-----| | Atmosphere | Vacuum | Air/inert gas + slag | | Gas removal | Excellent (H, N) | Moderate | | Inclusion removal | Moderate | Excellent (via reactive slag) | | Surface quality | Good | Excellent (slag skin) | | Segregation control | Good | Very good | | Cost | Higher | Lower | For the ultimate in steel cleanliness, some producers use a **double remelting** process: ESR followed by VAR (often designated ESR+VAR or "triple melt" when the primary melt is also vacuum-induction melted). This combination captures the inclusion-removal benefits of ESR and the degassing benefits of VAR. In the Japanese steel industry, Proterial (Hitachi Metals) and Daido Steel both operate VAR facilities. While the standard Yasugi Specialty Steel grades used for scissors (GIN-series, ZDP-189) are not typically VAR-processed, the technology is available for custom orders and specialty grades where maximum cleanliness is required. The aerospace industry is the primary driver of VAR technology, requiring VAR processing for critical rotating components in jet engines. The standards developed for aerospace applications set a cleanliness benchmark that benefits the cutting tool industry when manufacturers choose to specify VAR-grade material.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

VAR operates under vacuum and excels at removing dissolved gases (hydrogen, nitrogen). ESR uses a reactive slag and is better at removing oxide inclusions. VAR produces cleaner steel in terms of gas content, while ESR is superior for inclusion removal. Some premium steels undergo both processes.

VAR is not common in standard scissor steels, which are typically produced by conventional or ESR methods. However, the highest-grade steels used in specialty scissors and precision cutting instruments may benefit from VAR processing, and the technology represents the pinnacle of conventional steel cleanliness.

Related Glossary

Back to top