What is Hardness?

Description

Hardness is a material's resistance to permanent deformation, measured on scales including Rockwell (HRC for finished scissors), Brinell (HBW for delivery stock), and Vickers (HV for microhardness). The scissor industry uses HRC almost exclusively to specify blade performance.

What is Hardness?

Hardness is a material’s resistance to permanent deformation when subjected to an applied force. In the context of scissors and cutting tools, hardness is the single most discussed material property because it correlates directly with edge retention — how long a blade stays sharp between sharpenings. Multiple measurement scales exist, but the scissor industry relies almost exclusively on the Rockwell C scale (HRC).

Why It Matters for Scissors

Hardness is the primary specification that scissor manufacturers, retailers, and professionals use to communicate blade quality. A blade at HRC 60 will hold its edge approximately twice as long as an identical blade at HRC 56, all else being equal. This is why the HRC number appears in virtually every premium scissor product listing.

The scissor industry uses three hardness scales at different stages:

  • Rockwell C (HRC): The standard for finished scissors. Range: HRC 56-67 for professional blades. Most Japanese scissors target HRC 59-61 with VG-10 or GIN steels. Hayashi achieves HRC 63-67 with powder metallurgy.
  • Brinell (HBW): Used for steel in the annealed delivery condition. Proterial specifies HBW 272 maximum for GIN-series steels. This is relevant to manufacturers purchasing raw steel strip.
  • Vickers (HV): Used for microhardness testing of specific microstructural features. A carbide particle might measure 1,200-1,800 HV while the surrounding martensite matrix reads 700-800 HV.

Understanding that HRC is not the only factor is equally important. Two blades at identical HRC can perform very differently depending on carbide distribution, grain size, and toughness. HRC measures resistance to indentation, not edge stability.

Technical Detail
**Rockwell C (HRC) Scale:** The Rockwell C test uses a 120-degree diamond cone (Brale) indenter under a 150 kgf (1,471 N) major load. The test sequence is: 1. Apply a 10 kgf preliminary load to establish a reference position 2. Apply the 150 kgf major load 3. Remove the major load while maintaining the preliminary load 4. Measure the permanent depth of penetration HRC = 100 - (depth in mm × 500) This means higher HRC = less penetration = harder material. The scale is practical from about HRC 20 to HRC 70. For scissors, the working range is: | HRC Range | Typical Application | |-----------|-------------------| | 54-56 | Entry-level stainless scissors | | 57-58 | Mid-range professional scissors | | 59-61 | Premium VG-10 and GIN-5 scissors | | 62-63 | High-performance SG2/PM scissors | | 64-67 | Ultra-premium PM scissors (Hayashi HYS) | **Brinell (HBW) Scale:** Uses a tungsten carbide ball (hence "W" in HBW) pressed into the material under loads of 187.5-3,000 kgf. The resulting indentation diameter is measured optically. HBW values for annealed scissor steels range from 200-280. The Brinell test leaves a larger indentation than Rockwell and is better suited to softer materials and rough surfaces. **Vickers (HV) Scale:** Uses a diamond pyramid indenter under loads as low as 10 gf (0.098 N). The extremely small indentation allows hardness measurement of individual microstructural features — individual carbide particles, the martensite matrix between carbides, or the heat-affected zone near a weld. This is a laboratory technique, not a production quality control method. **Conversion between scales:** Approximate conversions in the scissor-relevant range: - HRC 58 ≈ HV 653 ≈ HBW 599 - HRC 60 ≈ HV 697 ≈ HBW 634 - HRC 62 ≈ HV 746 ≈ HBW 668 These conversions are approximate because each test measures a slightly different property (depth vs. area, static vs. dynamic response). ASTM E140 provides standard conversion tables. **Factors affecting measured hardness:** - **Retained austenite** reduces HRC — each 1% retained austenite lowers HRC by approximately 0.1 points - **Tempering temperature** — higher tempering reduces HRC (except during secondary hardening) - **Test location** on the blade matters — near the edge (thinner section, faster cooling during quench) may read differently than near the spine - **Surface condition** — decarburization creates a soft surface layer that reads low; grinding exposes the true bulk hardness

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Professional scissors typically range from HRC 56-62, with most premium Japanese scissors targeting HRC 59-61. Powder metallurgy scissors can reach HRC 63-67. Higher hardness provides better edge retention but requires more careful handling and professional sharpening.

A Rockwell C test presses a diamond cone indenter into the blade surface under a 150 kg load. The depth of penetration is measured and converted to the HRC number. The test leaves a tiny indentation, so it is performed on a non-critical area of the blade (typically the flat side near the spine).

Related Glossary

Back to top